Twitter feeds now coming to e-retailer conversations

October 7, 2009

Our electronic guru, Bruce Geroux is working to have all of our blogs post to our twitter feed. Stay tuned!


What is wrong with planograms by Tom Shay

October 3, 2009

Went to a friends store this week. There was a beautiful display of merchandise. It was easy to see that it was a planogram as all of the merchandise came from one manufacturer. The kicker was that there was a tip for a walking cane designed to be used when walking on ice.

Might be good in some places, but here in our part of Florida, I don’t think there is a lot of need for it. Of course, someone could buy it and take it up north with them. Then again, why don’t all stores in the south carry items that are suitable for usage in northern climates?

I think it is because the inventory does not turn. What’s wrong with planograms?

People don’t shop for merchandise according to brands; they don’t come in wanting an outfit of clothing that is all one brand. No one wants a sweater, pants, top, socks, and tie by Hilfiger. They come into the store looking for an outfit.

You don’t merchandise by brand; you merchandise a display according to how the customer shops.

You can’t build planograms such that one design works for every store across the continent. They have to be localized. This is what separates the independents from the chain stores – it is that local personalization that counts.

Worst yet, my friend never knew that the ice tip was even a part of the selection. Shame on her for not paying attention and shame on the vendor for putting things that don’t turn enough to earn their keep.


Tom Shay responds to why surveys stink

August 6, 2009

Actually,  I think customers satisfaction surveys don’t work because people don’t want to hear what the customer is really saying. The questions are designed to only give data that appears in a chart instead of listening to each customer on an individual basis.

Want to know what your customers think? Ask one question: ‘What could we do to make it easier for you to do business with us?’

Then read their answers, take action and respond to your customers. Here is a report on why the surveys don’t work.

Retail Customer Experience: Why customer satisfaction surveys don’t work

Commentary by William Cusick CEO and founder, VoxThrough a special arrangement, presented here for discussion is a summary of a current article from Retail Customer Experience, a daily news portal devoted to helping retailers differentiate the shopping experience.

Recent evidence suggests fully 95 percent of our cognitive processing is subconscious. That leaves all of five percent of the rational mind to do what it does best: rationalize (some might say “guess about”) our decisions and actions to ourselves.

What that means is we’re pretty poor at telling others what we like or don’t like, and why we feel that way. And the science suggests we’re even worse at predicting what we might like, or do, in the future. One might wonder then, if we’re so horrible at this, just why businesses continue to crank out standardized customer satisfaction surveys. How can you get closer to the truth, to determining real, actionable steps to drive customer behavior, when you don’t know what they’re thinking in the first place?

And there lies the real paradox: our actions are driven by emotion (in our irrational subconscious) much more than logic. Yet, to really understand your customers, you can’t look at those emotions. Instead you must take a step back, stop making assumptions and focus on their behavior. Behavior, it turns out, leads to the truth.

Paco Underhill, a self-described “retail anthropologist,” has understood this for a long time. In his book, Why We Buy, The Science of Shopping, he makes a compelling case for employing observation of customer behavior over other techniques like surveys. To help his clients get closer to the truth, he doesn’t ask customers; instead he sends his “trackers” out in the field to the actual retail environments, and observes customer behavior in real time.

It was through this power of observation that Mr. Underhill discovered what he referred to as the “butt brush factor.” He noticed that there were serious and unintended consequences when two product displays stood in close proximity to each other. If a customer wanted to bend down to take a closer look at a product on a lower shelf, it forced passersby to turn and shuffle by, resulting in said “butt brush.” This seemed particularly uncomfortable for women, and it meant very low sales on the products in those displays. The behavior, in other words, held the answer to an actionable improvement to the customer experience, and to desired customer behavior.

This same idea — that behavior is truth — holds in the online retail world as well. You can’t just ask customers if your website is “satisfactory,” or what improvements they’d like to see.

Can you see just what your customers are trying to do on your site? Where do they enter, and what path do they start down? Where are the road blocks? It’s been our experience that, once you look at the behavior, it’s not that hard to see where customers are abandoning the site, where they are stalling or backtracking, and more.

So remember, it’s not what they say, it’s what they do.


Tom Shay observes inventory control

July 2, 2009

You have probably read more than one article like this. The solution comes from first having reasonable expectations of sales. You should also know this is a great opportunity to get deals on merchandise from vendors.

Anticipate your inventory needs; underspend according to that anticipation and look for deals from vendors.

Summer spenders get cold feet

Weather, economic jitters strain retailers

BY ANNE D’INNOCENZIO, The Associated Press

NEW YORK – As consumers get ready to celebrate July Fourth, many merchants already have dismissed summer as a washout.

Macy’s flagship store has racks of summer tops, swimwear and dresses marked down as much as 50 percent, while luxury retailer Bergdorf Goodman is slashing prices on designer goods by as much as 70 percent. Meanwhile, piles of clothing as well as barbecue grills, tents and gardening tools are bypassing stores and heading straight to liquidators as merchants try to conserve their cash.

Such deep discounting so early in the season is great news for bargain hunters, but it’s a worrisome sign that shows a further weakening in retail sales since the end of May.

Consumers’ confidence in the economy, which had surged in April and May, is projected to be virtually unchanged for June when The Conference Board releases figures today.

Though unusually rainy weather across a broad swath of the country has slowed business, some analysts wonder whether shoppers are waking up to the harsh reality that the economy won’t be getting better anytime soon.

That doesn’t bode well for merchants, which need to get rid of summer inventory quickly to make room for fall goods that start to arrive next month.

BMO Capital Markets analyst John Morris estimated that the volume and size of discounts for mall-based apparel retailers he tracks is 10 percent higher than last June even though inventory is down 20 percent.

“It’s the economy, not the weather,” said Ahmed Youssef, a 28-year-old junior engineer from Jersey City, explaining why he has stuck to only necessities like groceries at Wal-Mart and computer accessories such as an $80 hard drive at Staples.

Pam MacWilliams, a tourist from Oshkosh, Wis., who on a recent Thursday was planning to scour for bargains at H&M’s midtown Manhattan location with her two girls, said she’s becoming less optimistic about a quick economic recovery.

“I thought that the economy would turn faster,” MacWilliams said. “I had high expectations. Now, I want to save more.”

Employers are still cutting jobs — although at a slower rate — and home prices are still falling, and now Americans are seeing a three-month stock market rally stall.

Consumers’ confidence in the economy has been rebounding since February, fueled in part by the stock market rise. But that improved mood hasn’t translated into much relief for merchants because confidence levels are still well below the measure that’s considered healthy.

Nor were Friday’s government economic reports comforting to merchants. They showed that households used most of their government stimulus payments to boost savings to the highest level in more than 15 years in May, instead of splurging at the mall.

“There was a lot of hope with the surge in confidence,” said Dennis Jacobe, Gallup’s chief economist. He added that consumers were convinced that the second half would be better but he noted, “you can live on that hope for only so long.”


Tom Shay agrees with those that say trade shows are a great investment

May 21, 2009

While this article from the Wall Street Journal is written from the aspect of a company exhibiting at a trade show, the logic is just as relevant for those attending a conference or trade show as a buyer or participant.

As I mention in our new presentation regarding the economy, every business has competitors that are making big mistakes during a challenging economy. Not being a part of a trade show means that the attendee is not seeing, hearing and learning what is the newest and latest within the industry.

A challenging economy ‘thins out the heard’. You don’t want to be a casualty because you failed to invest in learning what to do with your business. And by missing the trade show or conference, you won’t get to hear speakers such as myself providing you with business advise.

Need a Real Sponsor here

For small-business owners trying to navigate the economic downturn, spending money on trade and consumer shows might seem like a luxury better reserved for more prosperous times.

Not so, say many experts, who believe that exhibiting at—or at the very least attending—these events is one of the smartest things that a small-business owner can do, regardless of the state of the economy. Not only do exhibitions provide critical exposure to potential buyers, they also are essential for learning about unfamiliar markets, building personal relationships and getting an up-close look at the competition.

Conventions will always be one of the most valuable things you can do, says Andy Birol, owner of Birol Growth Consulting Inc., a business-coaching firm in Solon, Ohio. “There’s simply a consolidation of buyers in one place. They have money to spend and buying authority to exercise.”

Yes, exhibitions can be pricey. In addition to the cost of renting a booth or showroom space, exhibitors’ expenses typically include fees for shipping products and display materials. Many convention centers charge for drayage and access to resources such as electricity, phone lines and the Internet. Out-of-towners need to factor in transportation, lodging and dining expenses.

Such costs, combined with the bad economy, are leading some exhibitors to pull back. A recent survey of 240 corporate exhibitors found the number of conventions and trade shows they plan to participate in this year will decrease on average to 26 from 31 in 2008, reports Tradeshow Week magazine.

But that can be good news for small businesses, which are likely to see less competition at the shows this year. Plus, there are ways to minimize some of the costs that shows bring—and avoid others altogether.

Pick Your Battles

First, do some research to find out which shows are likely to offer the best prospects. Review sales figures from events you have attended in the past, including transactions that resulted from leads you obtained, recommends Jayme Broudy, founder of Contractor’s Business School LLC, an advisory firm in San Luis Obispo, Calif.

For new events, ask the registrars what kind of crowds they normally attract and how many of the attendees are actually buyers. Also request referrals to past exhibitors and buyers from within your industry and ask them about their experiences.

In general, if you must choose between an industry or a consumer show, Mr. Birol recommends targeting industry. Consumers are unlikely to spend big money in this economy, he says, and many go to shows just to have fun. For example, people who attend Comic Con, a comics convention held annually in New York and San Diego, commonly go there just to get artists’ autographs or to dress up like their favorite characters.

Once you know which shows you want to attend, consider offering to split the cost of an exhibit space with another firm in a different market. In January, toy distributor Rocket USA Inc. of Forest Park, Ill., partnered with a jewelry company to rent a showroom for a year at an Atlanta convention center. For $14,000, or half the total bill, Rocket USA will be able to exhibit at four shows and use the space for client meetings at any time during the year, says Cesar Vargas, vice president.

The discount on the yearlong lease, in addition to the partnership, resulted in a significant savings for Rocket USA, which Mr. Vargas says would have had to pay about $13,000 per show to rent its own booth. And the company will only have to pay to ship its display materials once each way for all four events, resulting in additional savings.

Mr. Vargas says that he connected with one of the jewelry firm’s executives at a gift-shop industry-association meeting. He suggests contacting trade associations, small-business groups and other organizations that cater to entrepreneurs and using networking sites such as LinkedIn.com to get the word out that you want to share a space.

When it comes to outfitting your booth, consider used display materials, says Aaron Rasmussen, co-founder of Harcos LLC, Santa Monica, Calif., the maker of Mana Energy Potion, an energy drink for gamers. In September, he spent $950 on a used backdrop that normally sells for $1,100 new. “Some companies buy them, use them once and return them,” he says.

He also recommends buying furniture for your booth from a discount store such as Ikea instead of renting it from the show operator. Not only are you likely to spend less, but you’ll be able to use whatever you buy more than once, he says. And be creative. At a trade show last year, Rocket USA displayed its products on the boxes it used to ship the items to the event.

Exhibiting isn’t the only way to find buyers at shows. You could skip the event and host get-togethers in a nearby hotel suite, says Mr. Birol. Many shows list registered attendees on their Web sites and in marketing materials in advance. Promote the opportunity as a chance to break from the noise and stress of the show and sit down in a private, relaxed environment, advises Mr. Birol. If you plan to introduce buyers to a new product or service, describe the meeting as a sneak preview.

Lend Your Voice

If your company sells services rather than products, offering to be a guest speaker at an exhibition is another effective way to win the attention of potential buyers without having to incur steep expenses related to exhibiting. You might even get paid for lending your voice.

Rebecca Morgan, president of Cleveland-based Fulcrum ConsultingWorks Inc., regularly speaks at industry events, earning about $1,000 to $5,000 per engagement. “My business is all about having credibility and being respected by people who are authorized to spend money,” says Ms. Morgan, whose firm advises companies about how to improve their operations. She adds that buyers often approach her about her services after she’s done speaking.

Before landing paid speaking gigs, you may need to get some experience doing it at no charge. Ms. Morgan recommends volunteering to speak at events hosted by local groups. Also, many shows line up speakers months in advance, so be sure to express your interest early on, she says.

As a last resort, you can always just walk the floors of an exhibition and introduce yourself to buyers. Also be sure to bring some product that you can give away to “anyone with a camera or microphone,” says Mr. Rasmussen. At a comic-book industry convention earlier this year, Mr. Rasmussen handed a sample of his company’s energy drink to video producers for The Review Zoo, an entertainment Web site. The crew responded with an on-the-spot interview request, and he happily obliged.

One final caveat: If your only goal is to be seen by your competitors, don’t bother attending a show at all, asserts Mr. Birol. “If you didn’t go, it used to be that the rumor mill would circulate and suggest that you’re not doing well,” he says. Today, this is no longer the case, because most businesses have a constant presence online, he explains.


Tom Shay says Southwest may be funny, but

May 14, 2009

So, how many of you have seen this new Southwest Airlines You Tube video?

Southwest Airlines rap

It may be funny, but there is also a lesson to be learned as detailed in this column I wrote from a trip I took on Southwest.

Always ON by Tom Shay


Macy’s strategy proves the point that Tom Shay makes

May 14, 2009

If you have heard my new presentation that deals with the strategy for a challenging economy, you will know that Macy’s is now doing exactly what I have suggested for our independent audience – take advantage of the mistakes your competition make.

If you have not heard this presentation, here is a link to a recording on the profitsplus.org website.

Strategies to win in 2010

RetailWire — The Power of Collective Thinking.
Other’s Loss is Macy’s Gain
05/14/09 By George Anderson

Macy’s has developed a strategy to take advantage of the misfortunes (specifically the move into bankruptcy and liquidation) of competitors such as Fortunoff, Gottschalks and Mervyns so it can pick up their customers.

“Wherever there is a store that has gone out of business, we are honing our sights on that customer,” Terry Lundgren, chairman and chief executive officer of Macy’s, told The Wall Street Journal.

Macy’s strategy, as The Journal article points out, is nothing new in retailing circles. In New Jersey, for example, even though Walgreens purchased prescription files from the failing Drug Fair chain, every pharmacy within miles of the former chain’s stores have signs posted letting consumers know their business is welcome.

Picking up a fallen rival’s customers is more important than ever considering the realities of consumer spending at this time. According to Deutsche Bank, closed chains in the clothing, electronics and home furnishings businesses left behind roughly $21.4 billion in sales this year.

Macy’s, as an example, is considering adding patio furniture to its stores in the New York area following Fortunoff’s collapse. Outdoor furniture, according to The Journal, was the most successful category for Fortunoff. The company has even talked with former execs at the chain about participating in an online launch of patio furniture this year with product to reach stores in 2010.


Be careful as you change your hours says Tom Shay

April 7, 2009

Hey, I all for businesses having shorter hours. This can especially help the independents level the playing field by not requiring the independent to match the hours. Personally, I don’t think the mass merchant is going to squeeze all their staff into the shorter hours. I believe they will continue to lay additional staff off and maintain their sparse staff.

My other concern is that it will be confusing to the customer when a business has too much of a variety in their hours; different days of the week have different opening hours and then open certain evenings and closing at various times. I saw a business that not only had a variation for all of the days of the week, but then they had two seasons and that had variety. All told, the store had 14 different schedules. Who is going to remember that?

Here is the article from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

Stores curtail hours as recession changes shopping habits
Tuesday, April 07, 2009
By Teresa F. Lindeman, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Todd Stillwagon, a Best Buy customer assistance supervisor, helps Mattie Williams, of Manchester, choose a Wii system for her 6-year-old granddaughter, Makai Williams at the store in Ross. The store will change the store hours to 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays beginning this week.

Retail hours have been stretching for years. No shopping on Sundays was replaced by the possibility of picking up diapers, milk and a new pair of shoes at 3 in the morning.

But the retail clock now may be heading in the other direction. Some stores and malls analyzing the payoff for later hours have decided the equation doesn’t work anymore.

“Typically after 9 p.m., we generally have more employees than customers in the building,” said Robert Smith, general manager of the Best Buy consumer electronics store in the North Hills Village shopping center in Ross.

Starting Easter weekend, his store and about 150 others in the Minnesota-based chain’s East Coast territory plan to close an hour earlier on Friday and Saturday nights, locking the doors around 9 p.m. instead of 10 p.m., although a customer just arriving then won’t be turned away.

Best Buy may save on energy costs and other administrative expenses, but the move isn’t meant to cut labor, said Mr. Smith. Instead, the retailer’s research indicated shoppers would prefer to have more staff available during peak hours than the option of coming in later.

Retailers are giving a variety of reasons for tinkering with their hours but the economic downturn and shopping pattern changes it set off were a wake-up call to use every minute as efficiently as possible. Keeping the lights on and the time clock ticking costs money.

When Dick’s Sporting Goods President Joseph Schmidt was asked during the Findlay retailer’s recent earnings discussion how the company had reduced payroll expenses, he mentioned Dick’s had reduced store hours.

Instead of being open from about 9 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. six days a week, Mr. Schmidt said the retailer had saved a little by opening a half hour later and closing a half hour earlier Mondays through Thursdays.

Earlier this year, mall owner Simon Property Group began closing its three Pittsburgh-area enclosed malls a half an hour earlier. Ross Park Mall, South Hills Village and Century III Mall all started shutting at 9 p.m. instead of 9:30 p.m.

A spokesman for the Indianapolis mall owner said Simon’s 17 properties in New England had done the same thing in January, in part to save on energy expenses and in part because of shoppers’ traffic patterns.

“We’re always looking to run our properties in an efficient and conservative manner,” said Simon spokesman Les Morris.

Last week, Monroeville Mall followed suit in trimming its hours, citing in part the changes by cross-market competition. Westmoreland Mall, which also is owned by CBL & Associates Properties of Chattanooga, Tenn., may follow.

Monroeville Mall marketing director Mindy Suhoza didn’t expect a lot of reaction from customers since the half hour past 9 p.m. was often mainly a cleanup time for mall stores anyway. But, she said, some people are quite pleased. “The store personnel love it,” she said.

Nationally, there have been reports that Cincinnati-based grocery chain Kroger has reduced hours for some stores that had operated 24 hours. So far, area grocers don’t seem to be making a lot of changes. O’Hara grocer Giant Eagle hasn’t, a spokesman said. A Shop ‘n Save representative also said he wasn’t aware of area stores cutting hours.

Some smaller retailers see the moment as an opportunity to be different. Joe Ravita at Empire Music in Mt. Lebanon last week began staying open later on Fridays and Saturdays. Instead of closing at 5 p.m., his doors will be open until 7 p.m.

“While other companies might be doing less, we’re going to be doing more,” said Mr. Ravita, who hopes that people walking by in the evenings may stop in when they see the lights are still on.

He couldn’t have made the move until recently when staffing changes made covering the hours feasible. But he noted his staff was small so his expenses wouldn’t be helped or hurt a great deal by an hour or two here or there, unlike a major retailer who might have 10 or 20 or more people on the store clock at a time.

Over in Shadyside, giftwares shop Toadflax has maintained store hours but trimmed costs by not replacing some staff who left for various reasons. It made sense to cut payroll hours that way, said co-owner Jeff Pierce, who noted business has been slower in the last several weeks.

Meanwhile, at Best Buy, Mr. Smith said shopping patterns have changed as the economy slumps, with customers staying home on the weekends more often. But he said business has held up, and it hasn’t hurt that competitor Circuit City just shut its doors.

Instead, he said, Best Buy officials were interested in research findings that shoppers looking for digital cameras or flat-screen TVs or computers had questions. “The customers told us they would rather have more employees here to help them during these busy times than longer hours.”

Area Best Buy locations cutting back on Fridays and Saturdays will not be shortening all weekend sales days. On Sunday, the stores will continue to stay open until 7 p.m.


A great way to close a sale

April 6, 2009

As I read this article, I thought what a great way to close a sale; not arrogant, but it says that the salesperson and the customer have found a common interest.

RetailWire — The Power of Collective Thinking.

Retail Customer Experience: The Retail Power of Suggestion

By James Bickers, Editor

Through a special arrangement, presented here for discussion is an excerpt of a current article from Retail Customer Experience, a daily news portal devoted to helping retailers differentiate the shopping experience.

Just down the road from my house is a great, locally owned, independent comic book shop that used to be one of my frequent haunts. Recently I’ve gone back in to reconnect with a hobby that I once loved.

The owner, an unassuming and quiet fellow named Doug, is there virtually all of the time. He has a deep love for and knowledge of his product, and is always happy to make suggestions about what to read next, based on what you’ve previously enjoyed.

Doug does something else that I didn’t notice at first, a powerful little trick of language: When he’s handing you your purchase and change, he leaves you with a phrase that, for lack of a better term, is a command to come back.

He doesn’t say, “Come see us again!” or “Thanks, please come again!” or any of the common parting shots. No, he says, confidently, “You’ll be back” or “You’ll enjoy” or “You’ll come back for more soon!”

It’s a tiny semantic difference, but a major psychological one. Like I said, I didn’t notice this at first – but when I bought the first volume of “Queen and Country” and Doug said “You’ll enjoy that, and be back soon for number two,” I immediately formed a mental picture of myself doing exactly that. About a week later, that’s precisely what I did.

Notice the level of specificity in his parting shot. He planted the seed for my next purchase by spelling it out for me. It’s not some nebulous idea of future business; it’s a description of a specific product that I’m going to buy in the coming days.

Visualization is one of the cornerstones of any flavor of self-improvement; it works because the human brain is so incredibly good at taking the things it sees and carrying out the next steps needed to make them real. This is precisely why Doug’s method is so powerful – it paints the brain a picture of the customer’s next visit, the next purchase, the next satisfying experience.

Fortune favors the brave, and business goes to the bold. A timid plea of “please, come back and see us” reaches out for pity, and sometimes that works. Much more effective is a simple and direct statement of what value the customer received, why they will want to receive it again, and what they will come back for.


Supply Chain Digest agrees with Tom Shay

March 17, 2009

An article from Supply Chain Digest today says what Tom Shay told audiences last fall; during the tough economic times there are lots of businesses that are going to make some very stupid decisions. One of those decisions they make is to cut inventory, and as they cut inventory they do so by cutting the worst sellers as well as the best sellers.

This is so wrong. You cut the worst sellers and put the inventory dollars into the best sellers so that you have the merchandise that the competition is not going to have.

You also look at the areas where the competition has made cuts and see if you can’t take that business that the competition has decided to leave unprotected.

Read the article below as well as follow this link to the free recording of Tom giving this presentation:

Little things to do to make ‘09 turn out fine by Tom Shay

Are Retailers Shooting Themselves in Foot with Low Inventory Strategies?

03/16/09

By Dan Gilmore, Editor-in-Chief, Supply Chain Digest

Through a special arrangement, presented here for discussion is an excerpt of a current article from Supply Chain Digest.

The recession has caused almost everyone to cut back on inventories, due to both a concern about customer demand and also because right now “cash is king,” and inventory uses up cash.

Nevertheless, I think many retailers may be taking it much too far, and costing themselves sales and profit as a result. Three recent personal anecdotes I hope make the point:

* Two weeks ago I went in a large mass merchant to purchase some mini-DVD tapes for our video work. Virtually every peg was empty. The only ones with product available were terrible deals. An associate there said they hadn’t received inventory in that area “for several weeks.” I walked out without a purchase – as I assume many others have as well.

* At a different mass merchant just this weekend, I needed to buy a gallon of anti-freeze for one of our cars. The shelves were simply decimated. In fact, I assume intentionally, they had taken some of the product that was still available (higher priced “extended life” anti-freeze) and moved it around to make it look like the shelf facings weren’t totally empty. That of course resulted in that product being placed above shelf labels that were for different, lower priced SKUs. I went down the street to an auto parts specialty store that had plenty of inventory and bought a gallon for $11.00.

* I was also at a major office products retailer this weekend. In addition to the usual no help for what I was looking for, as I was checking out I heard a woman at the service counter say this was the third time she had come to the store in the past few weeks looking for some item, and yet again it was out of stock.

Running “Lean” can be a good thing, and inventory management right now is a critical discipline. But from my view, many retailers have gone way beyond smart inventory decisions to ones that are detrimental not only to their own results but also to those of their suppliers.